C3 Patent and Intellectual Property Law

Feb052010 | Steve O'Donnell

Infringe? It’s a business decision.

A common question all attorneys get is “am I gonna get in trouble for this?” For some things your attorney will be able to give you a decent answer. . . “yes, that’s a really dumb idea” or “no, that’s fine,” but much more common is a more stereotypical lawyer answer of “it depends.” For intellectual property questions, I usually dredge up middle school algebra.

Every decision can be made with the help of an equation. Let’s say your burning question is "should I hit this guy at the bar that keeps looking at me?" The left side of the equation might be:

“(chance of me losing the fight)*(chance of me landing in jail)”

The right side of the equation might be “(how much would I love to pop this guy?)*(chance that the girl at the end likes macho jerks)”

If the left side of the equation is greater than the right side, not hitting the other guy is favored. Now, of course, you can’t know the real values of any of the variables, but you can estimate. If there is a chance that they guy is really looking at someone else or just has a facial tick, and he’s a 300-lb monster sitting next to his buddy the cop, well, stay seated and order another drink. If he’s obviously being a jerk, you’ve got 40lbs on him, there are no cops around, and you know the girl likes macho jerks, the equation favors popping him. Unknown variables are also in play: maybe he’s a ninja, or an android, or a ninja android. You can’t know everything, but the more information you have, the better your decision making process will be.

It’s similar to questions I get all the time concerning intellectual property. Only a fool would make an uninformed decision. Even a gambler willing to risk big is only going to do so after evaluating the chance of losing with the possible payoff.

It’s part of my job to identify and flesh out what variables are in play. If the question involves using an image for a blog post from and there is a plausible fair use argument, that’s one thing; if the question involves making and selling t-shirts with Mickey Mouse on them, that’s a much different equation.